Skip to main content

Problems 11.8 Problems

1.

A spherical body 1 of mass \(m\) moves along a horizontal support \(Ox\) of a referential 0 assumed Newtonian. The contact is characterized by coefficient of kinetic friction \(\mu\) and coefficient of rolling friction \(k\text{.}\) The initial condition corresponds to a forward motion of its mass center \(G\) at speed \(v_0\) and backspin at angular speed \(\om_0\text{.}\)
Figure 11.8.1.
Analyze the motion of body 1.
Solution.
The kinematics of body 1 relative to referential 0 \((O,\be_x , \be_y , \be_z)\) is entirely specified by the velocity \(\vel_G = v_G (t) \be_x\) of its mass center, and by its angular velocity \(\bom = \om (t) \be_z\text{.}\) Then the slip velocity of the body is given by
\begin{equation*} \vel_{I \in 1/0} = \vel_G + \bom \times \br_{GI} = (v_G + r \om ) \be_x \qquad{(1)} \end{equation*}
At time \(t=0\text{,}\) the slip velocity takes the expression \(\vel_{I\in 1/0} = (v_0 + r\om_0) \be_x\text{.}\) Since \((v_0+ r\om_0 ) \gt 0\text{,}\) the sphere initially slips, and we can assume that the initial phase of motion is also characterized by slipping.
Figure 11.8.2.
The external forces acting on body 1 are (i) the gravitational force \(m \bg\) applied at mass center \(G\text{,}\) and (ii) the contact actions assuming sliding and rolling friction. This gives the total action screw
\begin{equation*} \{\cA_{ \bar{1}\to 1} \} = \left\{ \begin{array}{c} - m g \be_y \\ \bze \end{array} \right\}_G + \left\{ \begin{array}{c} F\be_x + N\be_y \\ M_I \be_z \end{array} \right\}_I \end{equation*}
Application of the FTD \(\{\cA_{ \bar{1}\to 1}\} = \{ \cD_{1 /0} \}\) gives:
  1. the resultant equation \(m \ba_G = m \bg + F\be_x +N\be_y\text{,}\) or by projection on \((\be_x , \be_y )\text{,}\)
    \begin{equation*} m \dot{v}_G = F , \qquad N = mg \qquad (2-3) \end{equation*}
  2. the moment equation about point \(G\) (mass center of 1) \(\bD_G = \bM_G\text{,}\) or, with \(\bD_G = (d\bH_G /dt) = {2\over 5} mr^2 \dom \be_z\) and \(\bM_G = (rF +M_I)\be_z\text{,}\)
    \begin{equation*} {2\over 5} mr^2 \dom = r F+M_I \qquad (4) \end{equation*}
We have obtained 3 equations solving for 5 unknowns \(v_G\text{,}\) \(\om\text{,}\) \(F\text{,}\) \(N\) and \(M_I\text{.}\) We need two additional equations. They are provided by Coulomb laws:
  • We have \(F = - \mu N = -\mu mg\text{,}\) since the friction force \(F \be_x\) must oppose the slip velocity \(\vel_{I\in 1/0}\) (initially \(v_0 + r \om_0 \gt 0\)).
  • We also state that \(M_I = -k N = -k mg\) since moment \(M_I\) must oppose the rolling motion (initially \(\om_0 \gt 0\)).
Now we solve equations (2-4):
\begin{equation*} \dom = - {5g \over 2r} (\mu + {k \over r}), \qquad \dv_G = - \mu g \end{equation*}
showing that both \(v_G\) and \(\om\) are (linearly) decreasing functions of time. Eventually the slip velocity will reach the zero value. We obtain by integration
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ \om (t)= \om_0 - {5g \over 2r} (\mu + {k \over r}) t , \quad v_G (t) = v_0 - \mu g t } \end{equation*}
leading to the slip velocity
\begin{equation*} \vel_{I \in 1/0} (t) = ( v_0 + r\om_0 - {7\mu r+5k \over 2r} g t)\be_x . \end{equation*}
The slip of body 1 ceases at time
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ t_1 = {2 \over g} {v_0 + r \om_0 \over 7\mu +5k/r} } \end{equation*}
Time \(t_1\) corresponds to the start of the no-slip phase of motion of the spherical body: once it stops slipping, it continues to roll without slipping. At time \(t=t_1\text{,}\) mass center \(G\) takes the velocity
\begin{equation*} v_1 = v_0 - \mu g t_1 \end{equation*}
and body 1 has the angular velocity
\begin{equation*} \om_1 = \om_0 - {5g \over 2r} (\mu+ {k \over r}) t_1 \end{equation*}
At this point, the sphere may roll forward, stop or roll backward.
For \(t \geq t_1\text{,}\) the sphere rolls without slipping: \(\vel_{I\in 1/0} = \bze\text{.}\) The translational and rotational motion of \(\cB\) are now coupled:
\begin{equation*} v_G = - r\om , \qquad t \geq t_1 \qquad (5) \end{equation*}
Assume that the sphere rolls forward: \(v_G \gt 0\) and \(\om \lt 0\text{.}\) The motion is still governed by the equations (2-4). Now with equation (5), we find
\begin{equation*} F = m \dv_G = - mr \dom = {2\over 5}mr \dom - {M_I \over r} \end{equation*}
Since \(\om \lt 0\text{,}\) we must have \(M_I = kmg \gt 0\text{.}\) We can integrate to obtain \(\om (t)\) for \(t \geq t_1\text{:}\)
\begin{equation*} r\om = r\om_1 + {5k \over 7r} gt = -v_G , \qquad t \geq t_1 . \end{equation*}
Then we find that the motion ends at time \(t=t_2\) given by
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ t_2 = - {7 r\om_1 \over g} {r\over k} } \end{equation*}
The friction force is given by
\begin{equation*} F = - mr \dom = - {5k \over 7r} mg \end{equation*}
The condition \(|F| \lt \mu N\) imposes \(k/r \lt 7\mu/5\text{,}\) which is satisfied since the ratio \(k/r\) is expected to be much smaller than \(\mu\text{.}\)

2.

Consider the pendulum of example Example 11.3.1. It is assembled by connecting a body 2 of mass center \(B\) and mass \(m\) to a body 1 of mass center \(A\) and mass \(M\text{.}\) We examine the effect of friction on the motion of the system. More specifically, the contact between body 1 and its guide is characterized by coefficient of kinetic friction \(\mu\text{.}\) Body 2 can rotate freely about a frictionless pivot at \(A\) relative to body 1. The motion of the system occurs in a vertical plane. The position of the system at any time \(t\) is defined by the coordinate \(x(t)\) of \(A\) measured along axis \(Ox\) and by the angle \(\te(t)\) defined positively in the anticlockwise direction. The system is given initial conditions \((x_0,\te_0, \dx_0, \dte_0)\) (with \(0\lt \theta_0 \lt \pi/2\)). Denote by \(l\) the distance \(AB\text{,}\) by \(J =m\kappa l^2\) the moment of inertia of pendulum 2 about its axis of rotation, and by \(\delta\) the ratio \(m/(m+M)\text{.}\)
Figure 11.8.3.
  1. Denote by \(\bR = R_x \bx_0 + R_z \bz_0\) the reaction force exerted on body 1. According to Coulomb law \(R_x = - \epsilon \mu R_z\) with \(\epsilon = \pm 1\text{.}\) The actual value chosen for \(\epsilon\) depends on the sign of \(R_z\) and \(\dx\text{.}\) Show in all cases the quantity \(\epsilon \dx R_z\) is always positive.
  2. Find the three equations which solve for the unknowns \((x, \theta , R_x , R_z)\text{.}\) After using \(R_x = - \epsilon \mu R_z\text{,}\) express \(R_z\) as a function of \(\epsilon\) and \(\theta\text{,}\) \(\dte\) and the parameters \(\kappa\) and \(\delta\text{.}\)
  3. Assuming \(\kappa>\delta\) and that the friction coefficient \(\mu\) is sufficiently large so as to satisfy the condition
    \begin{equation*} \frac{\kappa}{\delta} -1 + \sin^2 \theta_0 - \mu \sin\theta_0 \cos\theta_0 \lt 0 \end{equation*}
    Show that:
    1. if \(\dx_0 \gt 0\text{,}\) no motion compatible with Coulomb laws is possible.
    2. if \(\dx_0 \lt 0\text{,}\) two possible motions are possible (starting with the same initial conditions!).

3.

The figure displayed below shows an experiment displayed in many science museums: a ball set in motion on a rotating turntable can display many surprising motions. The object of this problem is to examine a few properties of these motions. Consider a horizontal turntable \(\cD\) constrained to rotate uniformly about a vertical axis \((O, \be_z)\) fixed in some Newtonian referential \(\cE\text{.}\) A spherical rigid body \(\cS\) of radius \(r\text{,}\) of mass \(m\) is constrained to move without slipping on top of \(\cD\text{.}\) We denote by \(mk^2 r^2\) the moment of inertia of \(\cS\) about one of its diameters, by \(I\) the contact point between \(\cS\) and \(\cD\text{,}\) by \(\om\be_z\) the prescribed} constant angular velocity of platform \(\cD\text{,}\) by \(\bOm\) the unknown angular velocity of \(\cS\text{,}\) and by \(\vel_C\) the velocity of its mass center \(C\text{.}\) The quantities \(\bOm\) and \(\vel_C\) are defined relative to \(\cE\text{.}\)
We neglect rolling and spinning friction. The initial position vector and velocity of \(C\) and the initial angular velocity of \(\cS\) are denoted by \(\br_0 = \br_{OC_0}\text{,}\) \(\vel_0\) and \(\bOm_0\text{,}\) respectively.
Figure 11.8.4.
  1. Derive the three vectorial equations expressing the no-slip condition at contact point \(I\) and the Fundamental Theorem of Dynamics applied to \(\cS\text{.}\) Verify that there are as many unknowns as equations.
  2. Show that the spin component of the angular velocity of \(\cS\) remains constant, and that the velocity of point \(C\) satisfies
    \begin{equation*} \frac{d \vel_C}{dt} = \frac{k^2}{1+k^2} \, \om\be_z \times \vel_C . \end{equation*}
    From this equation, prove that \(C\) moves uniformly along a circular path relative to referential \(\cE\text{.}\) Find the radius of this circular path, the corresponding angular velocity and the position of its center. Show that the friction force acting on \(\cS\) stays constant in magnitude.
  3. Show that if point \(C\) is set without initial velocity \((\vel_0 = \bze)\text{,}\) then \(C\) remains fixed relative to \(\cE\text{.}\) Find the condition satisfied by the initial angular velocity \(\bOm_0\text{.}\) Find the friction force. Comment.
  4. The motion of the turntable \(\cD\) is produced by a motor mounted between \(\cE\) and \(\cD\text{.}\) Show that the couple \(\cC\) developed by this motor must be given by
    \begin{equation*} \cC = \frac{k^2}{2(1+k^2)} \om \frac{d}{dt} \br^2_{OC} . \end{equation*}
Solution.
Define unit vector \(\be_z\) along the vertical directed upwards.
a. Express the no-slip condition at point \(I\)
\begin{equation*} \vel_{I \in \cS / \cE} = \vel_{I \in \cD / \cE} \end{equation*}
with \(\vel_{I \in \cD / \cE} = \om\be_z \times \br_{OI}\) and \(\vel_{I \in \cS / \cE} = \vel_C + \bOm \times \br_{CI}\text{.}\) Hence we obtain
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ \vel_C = (r \bOm - \om \br_{OC} ) \times \be_z} \qquad{(1)} \end{equation*}
Call \(\bR = \bF + N \be_z\) the reaction force due to \(\cD\) on \(\cS\text{,}\) with \(\bF \cdot \be_z =0\) (the friction force). Then application of the FTD gives
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ N = mg , \qquad m\dot{\vel}_C = \bF } \qquad{(2)} \end{equation*}
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ mk^2 r^2 \dot{\bOm} = \bF \times r \be_z} \qquad{(3)} \end{equation*}
where moment equation (3) is obtained at mass center \(C\text{.}\) (1-3) give 3 equations for the three unknowns \(\vel_C\text{,}\) \(\bOm\) and \(\bR\text{.}\)
b. Take the time-derivative of (1) to find \(\dot{\vel}_C = (r \dot{\bOm} - \om \vel_C) \times \be_z\) and eliminate \(\dot{\bOm}\) by using (3):
\begin{equation*} \dot{\vel}_C = ( {\bF \over mk^2}\times\be_z - \om \vel_C) \times \be_z = ( {\dot{\vel}_C \over k^2} \times\be_z - \om \vel_C) \times \be_z \end{equation*}
Now expand the triple product to find (use \(\dot{\vel}_C \cdot \be_z =0\) since trajectory of \(C\) is in a plane parallel to \((O, \be_x, \be_y)\text{.}\)
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ \dot{\vel}_C = {k^2 \over 1+k^2} \, \om\be_z \times \vel_C} . \qquad{(4)} \end{equation*}
From (3) we immediately find that \(\dot{\bOm}\cdot \be_z = 0\) which implies that \(s(t) = \bOm \cdot \be_z =\) constant: the spin angular velocity \(s(t) - \om\) of \(\cS\) relative to the turntable remains constant.
Recall that trajectory of \(C\) is planar. Furthermore, equation (4) implies that the acceleration of \(C\) remains perpendicular to its velocity and that magnitude of \(\vel_C\) stays constant: \(C\) is necessarily in motion along a circular path relative to \(\cE\) at the constant angular speed \(\om_C= (k^2 /(1+k^2) ) \om\text{.}\) The sense of rotation of \(C\) is identical to that of \(\cD\text{.}\) From the expression of the normal acceleration of a particle, \(v_C^2 / \ro\text{,}\) we obtain the radius of this circular path
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ \ro = {v_0 \over \om } {1+k^2 \over k^2} } \qquad{(5)} \end{equation*}
with \(|\vel_C| = \text{constant} = |\vel_0| = v_0\) (and assuming \(\om > 0\)).
The position of the center \(A\) (fixed in \(\cE\text{.}\) of this circle is found by using the initial conditions: \(\vel_0 = \om_C \be_z \times \br_{AC_0}\) with \(\br_{AC_0} = \br_{OC_0} - \br_{OA}\text{.}\) We easily find
\begin{equation*} \br_{OA} = \br_0 + \be_z \times {\vel_0 \over \om_C}. \end{equation*}
The friction force is given by \(\bF = m \dot{\vel}_C = m {k^2 \over 1+k^2} \, \om\be_z \times \vel_C\text{:}\) it stays constant in magnitude.
Note that the condition of no-slip is guaranteed only if \(|\bF| \lt \mu N\text{:}\) this gives a lower bound \(\mu_{\min}\) for the coefficient of sliding friction
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ \mu > \mu_{\min} = {k^2 \over 1+k^2} \, {\om v_0 \over g} } \qquad{(6)} \end{equation*}
If \(\mu \leq \mu_{\min}\text{,}\) sphere \(\cS\) immediately slips upon contact with \(\cD\text{.}\)
Figure 11.8.5.
c. From (5) we find that the radius of the circular path of \(C\) becomes zero if \(\vel_0 = \bze\text{.}\) In this case, \(C\) remains fixed in \(\cE\text{.}\) But this particular motion is true only if the no-slip condition is guaranteed at \(t=0\text{:}\) from (1) we find
\begin{equation*} \bOm_0 = {\om \over r} \br'_0 + s_0 \be_z \qquad (7) \end{equation*}
denoting \(\br'_0 = \br_0 - r \be_z\text{.}\) The friction force is zero at all times from (2). Condition (6) is satisfied.
d. Apply Euler’s second principle to \(\cD\text{:}\)
\begin{equation*} \bD_{O, \cD/\cE}= \bze = \bM_{O, \bar{\cD} \to \bar{\cD}}. \end{equation*}
Assuming the constraint between \(\cE\) and \(\cD\) to be a frictionless pivot, we find
\begin{align*} \cC \amp = (\br_{OI}\times\bF)\cdot \be_z = (\br_{OI}\times m \dot{\vel}_C )\cdot \be_z\\ \amp = (\br_{OI} \times m {k^2 \over 1+k^2} \, \om(\be_z \times \vel_C )) \cdot \be_z \\ \amp = m {k^2 \over 1+k^2} \om \, (\br_{OI} \cdot \vel_C) \end{align*}
or
\begin{equation*} \boxed{ \cC = m {k^2 \over 1+k^2} \om {d\over dt}\left( {\br_{OC}^2 \over 2}\right) } \qquad{(8)} \end{equation*}